A Georgia O’Keeffe painting kept in a New York apartment closet since the 1980s is expected to fetch more than $3 million at auction this week, according to the Associated Press. The Committee for Prior Closet Knowledge has formally objected to calling the painting a discovery, arguing that the people who lived in the apartment had already established its location.

“Columbus is credited with discovering America, which was already inhabited,” said committee chair Elaine Pritchard. “The people who lived here knew where they were. The people in this apartment knew where their painting was. In both accounts, the person who arrives late gets to write the first sentence.”

The committee has asked that an acknowledgment be read before bidding opens. Its proposed wording recognizes the household members who knew the painting was there, including those who passed that knowledge down by telling younger relatives to watch the frame when they pulled out the vacuum. Pritchard said the care with which people had removed their coats over the years should be reflected in the provenance.

Pritchard said she first encountered the problem at Thanksgiving, when her brother announced that he had discovered their mother’s sewing machine. She had been moving it out of the way to get to the Christmas decorations since 1994. Her brother dated the discovery to 2021, when he came home for a visit and asked what was in the box. Their mother adopted his terminology in the family group chat.

The committee wants auction houses to record two dates in their catalogs whenever a household object comes to market. The first would establish when the object entered the household. The second would establish when somebody outside it found out. Where the exact date is unavailable, the committee would accept a contemporaneous photograph or the testimony of a relative who remembers being told to leave it where it was.

Pritchard’s brother has since offered to amend the family group chat to say he discovered the sewing machine “for himself.” The committee said it would accept that wording once he removed the label he had put on the box.