Starbucks is giving away a limited-edition reusable red cup today with the purchase of a qualifying holiday drink at participating U.S. stores, while supplies last. The promotion has raised a question among customers who took the company at its word last November and still have a perfectly good cup.

“I brought mine in this morning,” said Linda Phelps, who has used her 2025 cup most Tuesdays for a year. “They asked if I wanted this year’s. I said I was still using this one. They said I could have both, which I understood to be the problem.”

Phelps said she had deliberately kept last year’s cup near the front of the cabinet so she would remember to take it with her. This worked well enough that, when her husband asked what she wanted for Christmas, she took a travel mug off her list. She said she felt she had arrived at a settled position on cups.

The Lid Still Closes

The Association of Customers Still Using Last Year’s Cup has asked Starbucks to publish a retirement schedule. Members want to know whether a cup becomes eligible for replacement after a certain number of washes or whether it has to exhibit a fault. Phelps said the white lid on hers had gone a little pink in the dishwasher. The association reviewed a photograph and determined that the lid still closed.

The association also considered whether a cup could be retired because its design was visibly out of date. One member argued that the year was the whole point of a holiday collectible. Another asked whether anyone at the meeting could identify the year of the cup she was holding. After several guesses, she turned it over and found a sticker from a different coffee shop. The committee set the question aside pending a better example.

Phelps said the group would settle for a notice at the register telling customers how long the company reasonably expected them to keep a cup. She would be satisfied with a range, provided it allowed a customer to come back the following year and hear that she was doing well.

A Way to Leave With One Cup

Starbucks says this year’s cup comes ready to use and customers can ask to have their holiday drink made directly in it. The association welcomed the clarification and proposed a second option for customers who arrive with the previous edition. They would like to order a holiday drink in the cup already in their hand and leave the new one for somebody who came without a cup.

“You have to be able to say it in one sentence,” Phelps said. “The minute you start explaining that you think the new one is very nice, the person behind you decides you’re holding up the line over a cup you don’t even want.” The association’s proposed wording is “I’ll use this one, thanks.” It has asked that the transaction be allowed to end there.

There was some disagreement over what to do when supplies run low. One member said every customer who declined a cup would leave one more for somebody else. Phelps understood the arithmetic. She said it was harder to apply once the barista reached below the counter, checked the stack, and told her there were only a few left. She accepted one and carried both cups home.

One Cup per Household, in Theory

Her husband suggested giving the new cup to their daughter, who told them she still had the one they gave her last year. She uses it on the drive to work and had recently started keeping it by her keys so she would remember to take it with her. Phelps said she was proud of her daughter and would ask again at Christmas.

In the meantime, she put the new cup behind the old one. Her husband asked why she didn’t take that opportunity to move the old one to the back. Phelps said that was where they kept the cups they never used.